Makinde’s G-Wagon Gift: Between Political Double Standards and Unnecessary Suspicion | |▪︎ By Dr Peter Akande
Dr Peter Akande
Chief Yemi Soladoye’s intervention on the G-Wagon gift to the President-General of the Central Council of Ibadan Indigenes (CCII), Barrister Ajeniyi Ajewole, deserves attention, particularly because he is a former President-General who understands the history, responsibilities and institutional relevance of CCII. However, while I appreciate his concerns about preserving the integrity of the institution, I respectfully disagree with some of the conclusions and insinuations contained in his submission.
First, we must distinguish between legitimate concerns about public perception and the deliberate construction of suspicion around an otherwise simple gesture of goodwill. What exactly is wrong with Governor Seyi Makinde appreciating an individual who has contributed to the development of Ibadanland? Must every gesture from a sitting governor towards an Ibadan indigene be interpreted as political compensation, inducement or an attempt to compromise an institution?
Interestingly, many people on this platform have received similar gifts in the past, perhaps when they belonged to the same political camp or when the circumstances suited their political interests. There was little or no noise then. Why has a similar gesture suddenly become a subject of intense controversy? Is the problem really the gift, or is it the identity of the giver and the political camp to which the recipient is perceived to belong? We must be honest with ourselves. Consistency is an important ingredient of responsible public commentary. We cannot applaud generosity when it comes from our political friends and condemn the same gesture when it comes from those we disagree with.
I honestly do not understand when CCII became an extension of the Oyo State House of Assembly, where every decision, appointment, gift or disagreement must be subjected to political alignment and opposition. CCII is a socio-cultural organisation established to promote the collective interests of Ibadan indigenes. It is not a political party, neither is it an opposition platform against the government of the day. If the President-General takes a decision concerning the organisation, let us examine its merits, constitutionality and implications rather than judging it primarily by the political affiliations of those who support or oppose him.
I sometimes wonder whether some of the criticisms would disappear if the President-General removed Mogajis perceived to belong to opposing political camps or those whose political interests differ from his. Would he suddenly become a saviour instead of a subject of criticism? If that is the expectation, then we are no longer discussing the institutional independence of CCII; we are discussing political accommodation and personal interests. The President-General must be allowed to lead within the provisions of the organisation’s constitution, and those who disagree with him should offer constructive criticism without turning every disagreement into a political war.
On the New Olubadan Palace, Chief Soladoye has rightly identified several individuals and administrations whose contributions helped bring the project to fruition. Their contributions deserve recognition. Nobody should rewrite history or appropriate the collective efforts of others. However, acknowledging the contributions of previous leaders does not diminish the contribution of the present administration or the CCII leadership that eventually witnessed the completion of the project. David laid the foundation, but Solomon completed the temple. Both had their respective places in history.
Chief Soladoye mentioned several contributors, but he must equally acknowledge that Governor Seyi Makinde did very well in ensuring the completion of the palace. Whatever political reservations anyone may have about the Governor, that achievement cannot honestly be denied. One cannot deliberately minimise the contribution of a sitting Governor simply because of political disagreement. I hope we will not get to a point where somebody begins to describe Governor Makinde as an Ijesa man simply because he disagrees with his political decisions. That would be unfortunate. Who cursed Ibadan to the extent that we cannot appreciate our own sons and daughters when they make positive contributions to our land? Ibadan’s development should not be subjected to political ownership. Every administration and every individual who contributes deserves recognition.
Perhaps the most troubling aspect of the article is the suggestion that the G-Wagon gift has exposed or rewarded the silence of the CCII leadership over the Circular Road, Bodija explosion, Agodi Gardens, land issues and infrastructure deficits in Ibadan. These are serious issues that deserve independent and sustained attention. The people affected by the Circular Road project deserve fairness, the victims of the Bodija explosion deserve adequate consideration, and residents of Ibadan’s outer-city communities deserve good roads and other essential amenities. But where is the evidence that the CCII leadership deliberately abandoned these responsibilities because of a birthday gift? We must not confuse the existence of unresolved public concerns with proof of institutional compromise. If the CCII has failed in any of its responsibilities, let us identify the specific failures, demand explanations and insist on corrective measures. That is constructive criticism. But to suggest that a luxury vehicle is the reward for silence is to make an allegation that requires evidence, not speculation.
I also disagree with the attempt to create a contradiction between the pre-2019 Seyi Makinde and the present Governor. Before becoming Governor, Engr. Seyi Makinde was known for supporting community development initiatives with personal resources. His emergence as Governor does not automatically remove his right to maintain personal relationships or extend gestures of goodwill. Indeed, the office of Governor should not prevent its occupant from appreciating individuals who have made contributions to society.
We can hold Governor Makinde accountable for the condition of roads, infrastructure, compensation and other public responsibilities without suggesting that every personal gesture he makes is misplaced. If the road from the Post Office through Agodi Gardens needs rehabilitation, let us demand its rehabilitation. If the bridge between Agugu and Ode-Aje requires urgent attention, let us demand action. These demands are legitimate. But should we conclude that because the Governor presented a G-Wagon to an individual, he has committed an offence against the people? That argument does not sufficiently address the real issues.
Ibadan belongs to all of us, irrespective of political affiliation. Governor Seyi Makinde is a son of Ibadanland. Barrister Ajeniyi Ajewole is also a son of Ibadanland. The Olubadan remains the revered traditional father of our people, and CCII remains an important institution representing the collective interests of Ibadan indigenes. Respecting one does not amount to disrespecting another. We must stop creating unnecessary rivalry between political leadership, traditional institutions and community organisations. Their responsibilities may differ, but their collective interest should be the development, unity and progress of Ibadanland.
Chief Yemi Soladoye has every right to offer advice based on his experience as a former President-General. However, advice should not become a verdict, and suspicion should not be presented as established fact. Let us judge the Governor by his performance, the CCII by its responsibilities and the President-General by his conduct.
A gift should not purchase silence, but neither should generosity automatically be interpreted as an attempt to purchase loyalty.
Ibadan deserves responsible leadership, constructive criticism and unity of purpose, not endless political suspicion. We cannot continue to preach unity while allowing partisan interests to determine who deserves appreciation, who deserves criticism and who is qualified to lead our socio-cultural institutions.
Dr Peter Akande
