Political Empire Or Political Hyperbole ? A Response To “Gov Seyi Makinde Political Empire Collapsing Like A House Of Cards ” ||▪︎ By Dr Peter Akande
By Dr Peter Akande
Political analysis is legitimate, criticism is healthy, and nobody should be above scrutiny. However, political commentary becomes less convincing when assumptions are presented as established facts, defections are interpreted as the collapse of an administration, and every disagreement is conveniently attributed to the personal failure of one individual.
The article titled “Gov Seyi Makinde Political Empire Collapsing Like a House of Cards” is an interesting piece of political commentary, but its conclusion appears to be much stronger than the evidence presented.
To begin with, saying that Governor Seyi Makinde became governor in 2019 merely because of “fate, divine intervention and unexpected turn of fortuitous events” is an unnecessary attempt to diminish a political victory. Elections are won through a combination of circumstances, alliances, strategy, voter preferences, campaign organisation and, ultimately, the choice of the electorate. If providence played a role, that is not peculiar to Makinde; virtually every political victory can be described in similar terms.
More importantly, the coalition that produced the 2019 victory should not be romanticised as though Governor Makinde was merely a beneficiary who had no political relevance of his own. The coalition partners played important roles, but Makinde himself was the candidate whose name appeared on the ballot and who ultimately secured the mandate of the people.
Political alliances are not permanent marriages. They are often built around interests, principles, ambitions and circumstances. Therefore, when politicians who once worked together later disagree, it does not automatically mean that the political structure of the person they supported has collapsed.
The article also lists several politicians who have moved away from Governor Makinde and presents their departure as proof that his political empire is collapsing. That argument requires a more rigorous examination.
How many people have left is not necessarily the same as how many people support you.
A politician can lose some political associates and still retain enormous electoral strength. Conversely, a politician can have a long list of prominent supporters and still lose an election. Political strength is ultimately tested at the polling booth.
The 2023 election provides an important lesson. Governor Makinde did not merely survive; he won re-election with a very substantial margin. Whatever political disagreements existed around him, the electorate ultimately renewed his mandate.
The writer is also entitled to argue that Governor Makinde may have presidential ambitions. But describing such ambition as “disrespectful” simply because President Bola Ahmed Tinubu is also a Yoruba man is difficult to sustain in a democratic setting.
Nigeria is a federation, and every qualified Nigerian has the constitutional right to seek elective office. Political competition between people from the same ethnic group is not an act of disrespect. If anything, democracy requires that competence, acceptability, political structure and the electorate—not ethnic sentiment—should determine who occupies public office.
If Governor Makinde eventually contests for president, Nigerians will have the opportunity to assess his record, character, competence and political programme. The same standard should apply to every other aspirant, including President Tinubu.
The argument about the APC’s role in Makinde’s 2023 victory also deserves proper context. Political parties and politicians often cooperate tactically during elections. Such cooperation does not mean that one party owns another politician’s mandate. Governor Makinde contested on the platform of the PDP, and the electorate gave him a second term.
Therefore, saying that “the support of APC secured the victory for Seyi Makinde” is an interpretation, not an incontrovertible historical fact. The voters of Oyo State—not APC alone, not PDP alone, and not any individual politician—ultimately cast the votes that produced the result.
The reference to traditional rulers equally requires caution. Disagreements between political office holders and traditional institutions should not automatically be interpreted as evidence that a governor has lost political legitimacy. Traditional rulers occupy revered positions in our society, and their institutions deserve respect. At the same time, disagreement between a governor and a traditional institution should be handled with maturity rather than converted into evidence of an impending political collapse.
There is also a fundamental contradiction in the article.
If Governor Makinde’s political empire is truly “collapsing like a house of cards,” why is so much attention being devoted to his every political move?
Why are defections from his camp generating headlines?
Why are his political ambitions generating so much anxiety?
Why is there so much effort to catalogue the people allegedly leaving him?
Sometimes, the intensity of opposition against a politician is itself evidence that the politician remains politically relevant.
Political power is never static. People move from one party to another. Alliances are formed and broken. Political friends become opponents and former opponents sometimes become allies. That is the nature of Nigerian politics.
What matters in the final analysis is not the number of people who leave a political camp, but the capacity of the political leader to maintain public confidence and win elections.
Therefore, rather than declaring Governor Makinde a “drowning governor,” it would be more intellectually honest to say that Oyo State is entering another phase of political realignment ahead of 2027.
Makinde may gain political ground. He may lose some ground. His opponents may become stronger. New alliances may emerge. Old alliances may disappear. But nobody can honestly declare the final outcome before the people speak through their votes.
There is nothing wrong with predicting the political downfall of a governor. That is part of political commentary. But prediction should not be confused with prophecy, and political disagreement should not be mistaken for political collapse.
The ballot box, not social media, political rhetoric or newspaper headlines, remains the ultimate political courtroom.
Let the politicians campaign. Let the analysts analyse. Let the people decide.
And when the votes are counted, we will know whose political house is truly standing—and whose has actually collapsed.
Dr Peter Akande
